Thu03282024

Last updateSun, 20 Aug 2023 9pm

Back You are here: Home Library Islam Philosophy of Islam chapter 12 - Man Range of Man’s Choice and Will

Range of Man’s Choice and Will

Range of Man’s Choice and Will

In order to know the conditions, limits and the field of man's choice, to ascertain the effects of this power on him, and to find out what factors influence his way of thinking, we must take the following points into consideration:

 (1) Innate nature of man and his disposition

Man has many motives and instincts which pull him towards themselves. Some of his instincts are derived from a material source, and some others from a Divine spirit.

 You may call these instincts propensity, disposition, natural urge, tendency or inclination. Some most important of these instincts are as under:

 a. Inclination towards and need of food, clothing and shelter;

 b. The instinct of self‑defense;

 c. Sexual urge;

 d. Aesthetic sense;

e. The instinct of gaining position and respect;

 f. The instinct of seeking truth and liking it;

 g. Love of knowledge;

 h. Love of justice;

 i. Fellow‑feeling;

 j. Love of perfection and a desire to seek it.

 Such instincts and urges are interwoven with the innate nature of man, [25] and hence they are not transient and acquired. But still their existence does not mean that man is a captive of them. These instincts only bring about a sort of inclination and attraction. They work as a motive force, but they do not tie the hands of man. Man has the power to follow or not to follow them. It is within his power to satisfy his instinctive desires or to restrain them, to supervise and guide them or to change their direction.

 These urges are actually controlled by man's will based on his way of thinking.

 (2) Modification of Propensities

The modification of propensities and instincts is essential, though it is very difficult and requires a great deal of effort, awareness and hard work.

 It may be easily understood that each of the above­mentioned instincts is in itself a need of life.

 Should there be no sexual urge, there shall exist no motive for procreation and formation of a family.

 Should there be no inclination to food, man shall take no steps to meet his nutritional requirements and consequently he shall perish.

 Should man have no desire to gain honor and social position, he shall succumb to disgrace and humiliation.

 A desire to secure position and social respect can impel one to make fruitful efforts and to do social work etc. But if this very desire becomes too excessive, it may over­come all other motives and may turn into a lust for power and position. In that case man begins to worship the idol of power and becomes a tyrant. He may go to any extent and may adopt any means, including spending money­making flattery and taking any mean action. In some cases one may even bear hunger and any other hardships to gain one's selfish ends.

 Even after gaining power in order to maintain and enhance it, such a person may commit any crime ‑ and resort to telling lies, and intimidating and slaughtering people. [26]

 In other words he may trample upon the high values of justice, realism and benevolence. [27]

 We observe how one instinct can overpower a man if it is not properly checked and is allowed to exceed the proper bounds; but we must not forget that in this case the instinct becomes an idol which man creates for himself [28] by misusing his power of choice, and it is he himself who can break this idol and can promote his higher tendencies. He can check and reform those instincts which exceed the proper bounds, so that he may save himself from sinking into sin.

 "As for him who repents, believes and does what is right, it is hoped that be will prosper". (Surah al‑Qasas, 28:67).

 "But be who fears the position of his Lord and curbs his base desires, shall surely dwell in Paradise". (Surah al‑Nazi`at, 79:40‑41).

 "Those who are saved from their own greed shall surely be prosperous". (Surah al‑Hashr, 59:9).

 There are many other verses which strongly censure imbalance in tendencies and declare that the problem should be solved by making positive efforts to promote higher tendencies.

 The Qur'an considers man to be always responsible to make efforts to reform himself and to guide all his tendencies so that none of them may exceed its limits and shrivel the freshness of human nature.

(3) Role of natural and geographical environment

It is not possible that the natural and geographical environ­ment of a man should have no effect on his spiritual and emotional life. Just as the features and muscles ‑power of all men cannot be the same, similarly the spirituality of a man who has grown up in the scorching heat of a desert amidst sand‑dunes cannot be similar to that of another man who lives in a coastal region having humid climate and dense forests. There is no doubt that hot climate, salt water, or mountainous region cannot have the same effect on human tendencies as for instance, cold climate, sweet water or marshy land has. This is just as the physique of the people of all regions cannot be the same.

 However these varied natural and physical conditions do not compel a man to go in a particular direction though they may provide him to some extent a conducive atmos­phere to induce him to adopt a certain way of life. No region compels a man to maintain or lose his self‑respect, to defend his freedom or succumb to subjugation, to be virtuous or wicked or to be lazy or industrious.

 It is man himself, who in spite of all difficulties and unfavorable conditions, can find his way and use his will‑power to strengthen his constructive spirituality.

 (4) Role of historical, social and economic factors

The historical factors, social atmosphere, economic relations and social conditions also play a basic role in giving direction to man's tendencies, his motives, his outlook and his way of life. Some times they set up hurdles in the way of man's freedom and his power of choice.

 But we should not forget that the present conditions were brought about gradually by some people and other people can fight the existing evil factors under the banner of freedom and knowledge, can add to their intellectual matureness, and by using what remains of their will and decision‑making power can fight corruption. This subject will be discussed further while we deal with the historical outlook of Islam.

 (5) Role of the rules and regulations in the field of choice

 We have come to know that man has certain tendencies and instincts which must be guided and modified. As natural factors and environmental conditions affect his choice and his mode of life, he must take steps to improve his surroundings and change them for the better. The principles and rules on the basis of which this modification and improvement should take place, are one of the most important topics connected with the question of man's choice and his will.

 How should he mould his life and in what direction should he turn himself? What should he choose and on what basis? Should he allow others to impose certain principles on him and then of his own accord choose those very principles and go the way to which he is led in an invisible manner, as normally is the case in modern democracy?

 Or should he allow himself to be involved in an ideological conflict on the basis of the theory of material compulsion and historical dialectic as advanced by certain schools of thought, and by bringing about further contradiction in this process, invigorate the movement and development of history?

 Or should a man, as a principle, free himself from all principles already enunciated, get rid of his own pre­conceived ideas, and then with complete freedom make his choice and create his own principles and rules, because there exists no principle other than that which one himself chooses? Or is there any other way out? If so, what is that?

 From Islamic point of view, man has been created free from all such compulsions and no pre‑conceived principle or view can be imposed on him to deprive him of his free will and power of choice.

 Man should himself choose the rules and principles for moulding himself rightly and to serve his society in the light of his expanded knowledge. All the emphasis which the Qur'an lays on thinking, understanding and reasonable­ness and that too on the thinking free from whims, myths and the wrong notions prevalant in the environment or inherited from forefathers, is aimed at paving the way for finding the truth.

 (6) Divine revelation

One of the most important sources of knowledge and the domains of thinking is Divine revelation.

 The world is not dark and void. In addition to those inner faculties with which Allah has provided man in order to help him find the truth, He has sent Prophets to guide him aright. This guidance does not mean forced imposition of Allah's will, nor does it mean the suppression of the creative will of man. It only means a sort of exhortation and Divine help. It shows kindness and graciousness of Allah. This guidance is a light which adds to the insight of man and does not restrict his will.

 Man should get benefited by this guidance with his eyes wide open, and for that purpose, he should use his knowledge and insight. He should first think and evaluate, and only then make his choice. If even after identifying the truth, he persists in his disbelief, he shall stand condemned.

 In support of these points, there is enough evidence in the Qur'an. We have already quoted some verses.

 (7) Man's own deeds make his destiny

Another question which gives direction to man's will and choice is his giving attention to the fact that his deeds make his destiny and that every action of his shall have a reaction sooner or later. Man's future actually depends on his own deeds.

 The Qur'an says:

 `Man gets only what be strives for". (Surah al‑Najm, 53:39)

 "Corruption has become rife on land and sea because of the misdeeds of the people". (Surah al‑Rum, 30:41).

 It is the resistance of the people which prevents corruption.

 "If Allah had not repelled with the might of others, the earth would have been corrupted". (Surah al‑Baqarah, 2:251).

Paradise and Hell are the outcome and the reflection of the deeds of the people. "This is Paradise which you have inherited by your righteous deeds". (Surah al-Zukhruf, 43:72).

 "In fact those who commit evil and are engrossed in their transgression, shall be consigned to the fire in which they shall abide". (Surah al‑Baqarah, 2:81).

In fact the deeds of the people are preserved accurately and carefully.

 "These shall have a share of what they have earned. No doubt Allah is swift at reckoning". (Surah al‑Baqarah, 2:210).

As in this world everything is well‑planned and well‑managed and there is nothing futile and haphazard, all human deeds have a role and a constructive effect.

 This view makes it very clear that a man has to be very careful while making his choice. He is not allowed to set his hand to anything haphazardly and carelessly.

 It is also essential that he should choose only what is right. He must not take a decision light‑heartedly. That is why he is anxious and apprehensive. Perhaps it is this fear of Allah that leads one to practical piety. [29]

 (8) Aim of Man's efforts

Now let us see what should be the aim of man's efforts. We know that Islam proposes certain goals and principles and calls man to adopt them. This in itself is a blessing of Allah. But it is man himself who should choose his way thoughtfully.

 Prosperity and salvation

According to the Qur'an one of the aims of the efforts of man is to achieve falah which means salvation and prosperity.

 Fallah means the cultivator, who cleaves the land, prepares it for cultivation and arranges for all the conditions necessary for the growth and development of seed, which under the favorable conditions of soil and water shoots forth from land and with the help of natural forces increases in height and size.

 Similarly if man arranges the conditions conducive to his human growth and perfection in every sphere and all dimensions of his nature, he will become free from the shackles of selfishness and base desires. He will be able to take full advantage of his talents and potentialities and his higher instincts will take a firm root. Such a man is said to have achieved falah and to have `prospered'. The Qur'an declare that this prosperity depends on self‑making [30] modification of natural urges, [31] good deeds, [32] construc­tive and positive efforts, [33] resistance against the evil, co‑operation for the good, piety, [34] betterment of the environment, diffusion of virtues, prevention of corrup­tion [35] and the like.

 (9) Ideals and values

With one evolutionary jump man begins co hold an ideal for the sake of which he forgets himself, concentrating his attention on faith and the service of humanity. A stage comes when for the realization of his ideal he not only forsakes his pleasures and comforts, and his position and wealth, but even lays down his life.

 A scientist makes sincere efforts to make a discovery, not to serve a tyrant or to get fame or secure a reward, but to add to knowledge and to serve humanity.

 A sincere social worker makes efforts for the treatment of the sick for helping the afflicted and the hungry and for defending the oppressed, not for the sake of any reward or publicity and not in a just formal or a professional way, but for the sake of humanity and service.

 An ideological worker faces all sorts of hardships and dangers and makes sacrifices for the deliverance of a nation. What name will you give to such a man and how will you interpret his working for an ideal?

 There is no harm if you call him an idealist, for what he strives for, does not already exist as a reality, neither in nature nor in society. He only perceives it as an ideal in his mind and makes it a part of his life. This ideal becomes a driving force which moves him to continue his efforts till what was a mere idea, is realized and becomes a historical fact.

 Every ideological school must have an ideal, which though does not already exist as a reality, but sacrifice should be made to achieve it. This is a thing which no theory of material compulsion can explain. It cannot be judged by any scientific standard, nor can it be interpreted by any material or natural law.

 These very ideals are the high values to which one should dedicate himself and for the sake of which one should make sacrifice. If you want to find a person who really possesses `human' qualities, you should look for one who is dedicated to these ideals and values, which are beyond the scope of physiological and biological laws.

 (10) Seeking Allah and Truth

Islam maintains that these values in their highest form are concentrated in Allah, and the man of Islam is enamoured of this absolute perfection. He is fit to yearn for and move towards the source of all virtues and values. A man having a perfect faith actually moves towards this goal. This absolute perfection is a pure reality and the essence of existence, which has created values and power. This truth cannot be perceived by material thinking, which cannot go beyond matter and energy and cannot think of reality and value or the source of power and motion.

 As far as man is concerned, it is he himself who begins his move towards perfection, though he is invited and attracted towards it by Allah, but not to the extent of compulsion and imposition, for in that case his move will have no value. He himself is responsible to make the journey with untiring efforts to reach his goal. How encouraging this promise is!

 `Man, strive hard to get closer to your Lord, and so you will certainly receive the recompense (of your deeds)': (Surah al‑Inshiqaq, 84:6).

You have no rights to post comments

Find us on Facebook